How to tell a real Black Friday deal from a one-day dip — what eleven days of price checks show

By Merry
At a glance
The three that vanished
On Friday 13 November, Best Buy cut three prices at once. The Apple Watch Ultra 3 went from $649 to $549. The iPad Air M4 went from $749 to $729.99. The iPhone 17 Pro went from $1,099.99 to $1,069.99. By this morning, Monday 16 November, all three were gone. The Ultra 3 is $649 again, still $150 off its $799 list price but no longer the deal it was. The iPad Air M4 is $749 again. The iPhone 17 Pro is back at $1,099.99, its $30 Holiday Deal gone entirely. Three drops, three reversals, all inside one weekend. What they had in common is the pattern: a cut that appeared in a single day’s check, on a Friday, with no history behind it. A price that falls on Friday and is back on Monday was never a repricing. It was a dip, and dips reverse.The two that held
Two of Friday’s drops are still standing, and the difference is visible in the data. The Apple Watch Series 12 is $479 for a second day, down from $549, a $70 Holiday Deal saving. The Garmin Venu 4 is $499.99 for a fourth day, down from $549.99, $100 off its $599.99 list price. A held price is the first sign of a real deal: the retailer has decided the new price is the price, not a one-day experiment. Both are first-party Best Buy prices, both in stock, both checked again this morning. If you were waiting for either of these, the wait is over — the price has now survived a weekend, which is more than Friday’s three managed.Today’s two real drops
Today brought two more, and both pass the tests the vanished three failed. The Galaxy Tab S11 is $699.99 at Best Buy, down $300 from the $999.99 it cost in every one of our checks since 5 November. Eleven days at full price, then a 30 percent cut — that is what a genuine repricing looks like in our data. At $699.99 it is $49.01 less than the iPad Air M4, which is back at $749, and $499 less than the iPad Pro M5 at $1,199, and the S Pen is in the box where Apple’s Pencil is an extra purchase on top. The Galaxy S26 Ultra is $1,050 at Walmart, down from $1,130.69 — and the seller changed with the price. It was a HotDeals marketplace listing; it is now sold by Walmart.com itself, at “was $1,144.22, you save $94.22”. It is the lowest price we have tracked for the phone since our checks began, against a range of $1,104.29 to $1,150. A long hold plus a first-party seller plus stock on hand: that is the combination that reads as a deal rather than a dip.The prices that are not deals
Not every lower number is a lower price you can actually pay. The Galaxy S26 FE fell $150 to $549.99 at Walmart — and it is still out of stock, for a sixth day. A price on a phone you cannot buy is not a deal, it is a placeholder. The Galaxy S26 at $774.99 is a marketplace seller’s price, and the seller changed again this morning, from Spice Mobile to HotDeals. The Galaxy S25 at $699.97 is sold by Reliant Cellular, and the Galaxy S25 Edge at $634.95 by Wireless Connections — both marketplace, both moving with the seller rather than the product. Marketplace prices are not false, but they are fragile: the seller, the variant and the stock can all change overnight, and the “deal” can disappear without the retailer ever changing its own price. Judge a deal by the retailer’s own price, not by the cheapest name on the page.Three checks before you buy this week
First, has the price held for days before the cut? A phone that sat at full price for a week and then fell is being repriced. A phone that fell yesterday with no history behind it is being tested. Second, is the seller the retailer itself? Best Buy and Walmart’s own listings hold; marketplace sellers turn over. Third, is it in stock at that price, in the variant you want? An out-of-stock price is a rumour, not a deal. If all three answers are yes, buy. If any one is no, wait — Black Friday is eleven days away, and a drop that is real today will very likely still be there, or be beaten, on the day itself.If you are buying this week
The pick list from today’s checks is short. The Galaxy Tab S11 at $699.99, with the pen in the box, is the tablet to buy — it undercuts the iPad Air M4 by $49.01 and the iPad Pro M5 by $499, and the cut has eleven days of full price behind it. The Apple Watch Series 12 at $479 and the Garmin Venu 4 at $499.99 have both held their drops through the weekend. Wait on the three that reversed: the Ultra 3, the iPad Air M4 and the iPhone 17 Pro may well drop again for Black Friday, and if they do not, you have lost nothing — their list prices are exactly where they were. The market will move again this week. Buy the drops that last, and let the dips pass.Sources
- CompareIdea price watch, 16 November 2026 — Galaxy Tab S11 $699.99, Galaxy S26 Ultra $1,050.00, Apple Watch Ultra 3 $649.00, iPad Air M4 $749.00, iPhone 17 Pro $1,099.99, Apple Watch Series 12 $479.00, Garmin Venu 4 $499.99, Galaxy S26 FE $549.99 out of stock, Galaxy S26 $774.99, Galaxy S25 $699.97, Galaxy S25 Edge $634.95, iPad Pro M5 $1,199.00, all checked 16 November 2026.
- CompareIdea price watch, 5–15 November 2026 (12 snapshots) — Tab S11 held $999.99 for eleven days; S26 Ultra range $1,104.29–$1,150.00; Series 12 dropped to $479.00 on 15 November; Venu 4 dropped to $499.99 on 13 November; Ultra 3, iPad Air M4 and iPhone 17 Pro dropped on 13 November and reversed on 16 November.
- Best Buy — Samsung Galaxy Tab S11 listing (https://www.bestbuy.com/product/samsung-galaxy-tab-s11-11-128gb-wi-fi-with-s-pen-gray/JJGRF39WLC).
- Walmart — Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra listing (https://www.walmart.com/ip/Samsung-Galaxy-S26-Ultra-256GB-Smartphone-Unlocked-Black/19199350891?variantFieldId=actual_color&classType=VARIANT&athbdg=L1600).
- Best Buy — Apple Watch Ultra 3 listing (https://www.bestbuy.com/product/apple-watch-ultra-3-gps-cellular-49mm-titanium-case-with-black-ocean-band-black-2025/JJGCQL3V5S).
- Best Buy — Apple iPhone 17 Pro listing (https://www.bestbuy.com/product/apple-iphone-17-pro-256gb-cosmic-orange-unlocked/JJGCQLQJ5X).
Last updated: 16 November 2026
Why you can trust CompareIdea: every price checked live across stores — never an expected price, never a conversion.
